I realize as of late, I have chosen topics that are rather edgy. I do not consider myself an authority or expert on any of these topics.
My writings are a reflection of sincere thoughts and an honest pursuit of truth which is geared toward offering the most help I can, for some of the complicated issues we face. Today is no different.
I have been asked multiple times about loved ones who were believed to have been Christian, who at some point in their life, felt hopeless and committed suicide, as to whether they went to heaven. In short, the question was: do people who commit suicide go to heaven?
There are several factors that come into play from a Christian perspective that make “suicidal Christians” the subject of such heated debate. Stay tuned as I will share my thoughts after I introduce you to some of the things I was told such as:
- People who commit suicide are frequently hopeless. How could someone who is a Christian ever feel hopeless? If they in fact felt hopeless and took their lives, they could not have been a Christian
- Suicide is murder and murder is sin. The wages of sin is death and a person who committed suicide could not have been a Christian
- Therefore they did not go to heaven
The first bullet statement deals with the myth that a Christian cannot have any internal struggles which at times paralyze them from seeing things the way they truly are. We must understand what Augustine taught concerning original sin—that it affected, marred and corrupted everything about mankind to include our chemistry, perception, and mind and this world is currently in an abnormal state. Things are not the way God intended them to be. All of creation is groaning waiting for the day of redemption (see Romans 8:19-23).
We may venture through the scriptures and discover people who loved God, were used by God to accomplish great things and who struggled with episodes and times of chronic depression: Job, Elijah, King David, Jeremiah (the weeping prophet), Jesus (my soul is exceedingly sorrowful even unto death, known by Isaiah the prophet as: a man of sorrows and acquainted with grief Isaiah. 53:3-12).
History reveals others such as: John Calvin, Susannah Wesley, Martin Luther, Charles Spurgeon, etc…. who struggled with moments and extended periods of depression and a sense of hopelessness. What are we to make of their life—that they could not have been a Christian because they sometimes felt hopeless or depressed and at times wanted to die?
Personally, a year ago, I was as low as I had felt in twenty years. I loved God, but I sank to an all time low. I felt hopeless and literally wanted to die. I could not and did not want to pray, read my bible, study, or worship. I felt hopeless. You may say: I understand but you are still here. You did not take your life. Correct, but I wanted to and I thought about it a lot.
*I will share more of my personal struggle at a later date and tell you what and who pulled me through that dark time.*
Think this through with me for a minute. The heart of those bullet statements strike at the central issue of the Protestant Reformation—how a person is justified in the sight of God. Those who say that a person who feels hopeless and who subsequently takes their life could not have been a Christian are in essence saying: the way a person lives their life—how well they perform is how they are justified—a salvation based upon works rather than faith.
Conversely, the Bible says: there is none good, no not one, all have gone astray (Rom 3:10-18); that we are justified by faith and have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ (Rom 5:1-2).
The Pharisees performed the externals of devotion to God better than everyone and Jesus called them “whitewashed tombs, and hypocrites”…. He said that we must have a righteousness that exceeded the righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees (Matt 5:17-20). If we cannot out-perform the hypocrisy of the religious leaders of Jesus’ day, we must receive our righteousness from another who did and who fulfilled God’s requirement (see Matt 5:17 and Php 3:8-11).
The first bullet statement excludes Christ as the ONLY proper object for anyone’s faith and secondly it leaves a person believing they can and must, master the sin nature and the effects of sin independently. The statement leaves us believing the effects of sin were not devastating enough and can be easily conquered. Why was it necessary for Jesus to die then? What did He redeem His elect from?
They are telling a hurting family that eternity in heaven depended entirely on what they did instead of what Christ did for them at the cross. While murder is sin, so is lust, adultery, hatred, sexual immorality etc…. Are we to conclude that a person who lusts and claims to be a Christian cannot be one and could never struggle with lust? Are we categorizing sins—writing some off as no big deal while others deserve the full weight of God’s justice? The scripture says: “The wages of sin is death…” (Rom 3:23). All sin deserves punishment.
Here is the beautiful thing about the Christian faith from Is. 53:4-6
“Surely he has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows; yet we esteemed him stricken, smitten by God, and afflicted. 5 But he was wounded for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities; upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his stripes we are healed. 6 All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned—every one—to his own way; and the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all.[1]
Jesus died for us, to rescue us from this present evil world. Depression is an extremely complex issue and should not be treated with such contempt by those who battle other demons. Furthermore, it is unjust, and unkind to squeeze everyone into the cookie cutter mold and toss random bible band-aid passages on gushing wounds such as: “the joy of the Lord is our strength” without taking the time or demonstrating the compassion to deal with issues responsibly.
This is our effort to heal wounds and when we do so in such nonchalant, cavalier ways, we are healing them lightly, saying: “peace, peace, when there is no peace….” When you do not understand and are not looking to understand, silence is golden. The highest form of ignorance is to condemn something you know nothing about.
So, do people who commit suicide go to heaven? I would have to know more about the person before making such a call. Who or what were they trusting in? What was the object of their faith?
I personally believe it is entirely possible for a person to love God, be a Christian and struggle with depression and a sense of hopelessness to the extent they take their lives and still go to heaven. Why? Because I believe it is entirely possible for a person to love God, be a Christian, commit adultery and still go to heaven.
This does not mean I am justifying sin. This is simply a strong belief that God has justified the sinner based entirely on faith in the merits of what Jesus Christ did at the cross, not on how well they perform or lived under the myth of perfection in this life! It is based upon a strong belief that sin has devastated, in fact rendered a death blow to humanity and hopelessness, suicide, lust and adultery are but a few of the results. The object of one’s faith is the critical issue to be resolved here.
There are people who will live moral and ethical lives who will not go to heaven. Why? It is the object of their faith! All of our righteousness before God is as “filthy rags…, event the plowing of the wicked is sin.” It is not good enough! If what we do or could do was good enough, Jesus would never have had to die on the cross to rescue us from anything. We could have mastered it all in our own industry!
I would offer this to a person, who is a Christian and who feels hopeless right now, to the extent of wanting or planning to take their life, that tomorrow offers opportunities that was clouded by the troubled perceptions of today! It could be better. You have tremendous reasons for hope. You are not alone in your struggle.
Suicide is selfish. You are not just taking your life, you are taking the life of those who love you and will be left picking up the pieces when you are gone. Do not fall into the trap of believing that your situation is so unique, nobody could understand, help or relate.
Though God may not send the pain, He will not waste any of it. Even if God seems distant, I can assure you, during your period of loneliness and isolation that God is doing a marvelous work of transformation to which you may not understand until after the fact. Life is precious and worth it!
With and in love
Pastor Mike
[1] http://www.gnpcb.org/esv/search/?q=Isaiah+53&src=esv.org
The quest for truth, that is, what is REAL has been the subject of inquiry and debate by philosophers and theologians for thousands of years. To say that Truth is unknowable is a contradictory statement because: the statement makes a truth claim.

What is the chief goal in life? Is it personal pleasure and happiness? Do we pursue personal pleasure and happiness because our life in its unvarnished reality is so pathetic?
The following is a small portion of my thoughts on the types of pressure that exists within the Church/Christian community, among it’s followers to be something other than human. Now mind you, I love Church deeply and am committed to serving in it and doing the work of the Church for the remainder of my life. Let me explain.
What is a greater gift Christians can give to those who are suffering? I realize it is entirely “human” or natural to question the reality of God’s goodness when pain and suffering are experienced. Certainly, mass amounts of devastation and suffering make us or should make us tremble.
Do you ever wonder what the person asked to do your eulogy will say? I personally do not plan on having a funeral with a casket. I am planning on donating everything I am physically and everything I can to help save lives the moment I die and am with my Lord in heaven.